New York Judges Block Trump’s Truck License Policy
New York judges halt Trump administration’s attempt to end illegal migrant trucker licenses, citing retroactive rule issues.
1 min read
On a recent ruling, an appeals court in New York has stalled the Trump administration’s effort to cancel the commercial trucker licenses of undocumented immigrants. A three-judge panel of the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that New York does not have to apply past cases to the new regulations preventing states from issuing CDLs to migrants whose legal residency has expired.
Legal Battle Over Federal Funding
The case centers on the federal government’s decision to withhold highway funding from New York over the state’s refusal to comply with the Trump administration’s new rule. The rule requires states to consider a migrant’s legal residency status when issuing commercial driver licenses and to ensure the licenses are not valid after the end of their legal residency date.
New York officials refused to cancel the licenses of non-domiciled drivers, arguing the new regulations could not be applied retroactively. The state sued the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA), claiming the withheld federal funding was unjustified because the new rules did not exist when the licenses were issued.
Split Decision on Retroactive Application
The court ruled that the agency could not withhold federal funding based on a state’s noncompliance with a regulatory requirement that did not exist. Even Judge Matthew A. Schwartz, a Trump appointee, agreed that the case should be decided based on the statutes in place at the time, which did not mention anything about legal residency dates.
This case only concerns the withholding of transportation funding. A separate lawsuit is still ongoing, challenging the new rule tying CDLs to legal residency dates. The ruling highlights the ongoing legal and administrative battle over immigration policy and its impact on commercial transportation.
Source: Breitbart