California School Votes to Expel 9-Year-Olds for Refusing Transgender Pronouns
Elk Grove Unified School District prepares to vote on policy penalizing students for not using transgender students’ chosen names and pronouns.
2 min read
Elk Grove Unified School District is set to vote on a policy that could lead to the suspension or expulsion of students as young as nine years old for refusing to use transgender students’ chosen names and pronouns. The proposed regulation, which has already been approved by the board in October 2024, outlines disciplinary actions for students in grades 4 through 12, including possible suspension or expulsion, and staff disciplinary measures up to dismissal.
Policy and Concerns
Board Policy 5145.18 does not explicitly mention pronouns, but the administrative regulation implementing the policy does. Trustee Heidi Moore, representing Area 7, has raised concerns about the policy, stating it may infringe on students’ First Amendment free speech rights and religious protections. Moore, who joined the board after the 2024 vote, has previously been the sole dissenter on transgender-related issues, including girls’ sports and Pride Month proclamations.
Regulation Details
The regulation defines conduct that may constitute gender-based harassment, with one example being the refusal to address a student by their chosen name and pronouns. It states that disciplinary action for students in grades 4-12 may include suspension and/or expulsion, provided that the entire circumstances of the incident are considered. Fourth graders, typically nine years old, are included in this policy, which some argue conflicts with traditional beliefs and teachings found in religious texts, such as the Genesis verse, ‘Male and female he created them.’
Broader Implications
The regulation is not unique to Elk Grove; at least ten other California districts and one county office of education use similar language, treating the refusal to use preferred names and pronouns as gender-based harassment. Greg Burt, vice president of the California Family Council, criticized the policy, stating it misrepresents disagreement as harassment and bullying, and that it undermines the right of students to express their religious beliefs without fear of punishment.
Upcoming Vote
The board is set to vote on the policy during a meeting scheduled for Tuesday at the Robert L. Trigg Education Center in Elk Grove. The policy has sparked significant debate, with critics arguing that it infringes on free speech and religious rights, while supporters maintain it promotes a safe and inclusive environment for all students.
Source: The Gateway Pundit