Charlotte City Seeks Dismissal of Zarutska’s Wrongful Death Lawsuit

0

Charlotte city officials move to dismiss lawsuit over fatal light-rail stabbing of Ukrainian refugee Iryna Zarutska.

A memorial setup includes a framed photo, stuffed animals, flowers, and a candle, likely honoring a loved one.

2 min read

Charlotte, North Carolina, is seeking to dismiss a wrongful death lawsuit over the fatal stabbing of Iryna Zarutska, a 23-year-old Ukrainian refugee, aboard a light-rail train last summer. City attorneys filed a motion with a Mecklenburg County Superior Court judge on Monday, arguing that the city is shielded by governmental immunity and cannot be held liable for the attack.

Legal Arguments and Defense

The motion asks the judge to dismiss the case ‘with prejudice,’ which would prevent the family from refiling the lawsuit. This comes after a failed mediation session between Zarutska’s uncle and city representatives. The city is the first to publicly respond to the family’s claims, which include allegations that the light rail had no security and that fare enforcement was lacking.

The family’s lawyer, Lauren Newton, asserts that basic fare enforcement and proper security could have prevented the attack. She also claims the city had the financial means to implement such measures. The lawsuit notes that four people died on or near the Blue Line in the months before Zarutska’s death.

Victim and Perpetrator Details

Zarutska was heading home from her shift at a pizzeria on August 22, 2025, when she was knifed in the neck by Decarlos Brown Jr., a homeless man with a long criminal record. Surveillance footage of the attack sparked nationwide outrage. Brown, who has a history of mental health issues, is in federal custody, and his murder trial has been postponed until May 2027.

City’s Legal Defense

City attorneys Lori Keeton and Terry L. Wallace called Zarutska’s death tragic but placed the blame squarely on Brown. They denied that Charlotte ignored passenger safety, stating the transit system already had an extensive security program. The city raised governmental immunity and the ‘public duty’ doctrine as defenses, arguing that local governments cannot be sued for failing to protect citizens from criminals.

The city also argued that the system-wide crime numbers cited by the family do not prove that a deadly attack was foreseeable. They claimed Brown’s act was an ‘independent, superseding cause’ that breaks any chain of blame. If the lawsuit proceeds, Charlotte wants the judge to cap any payout at $1 million, the state’s legal limit.

Source: Daily Wire

Written by
Connor Davis

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *