Peltola’s Victory Over ‘Other’ Sullivan Sparks Legal Battle
Alaska Senate race reveals alleged voter confusion and legal challenges over ballot strategy.
2 min read
Democratic Alaska Sen.-elect Mary Peltola secured her victory with a significant margin, receiving over 13,000 more votes than the other candidate named Dan Sullivan, according to The Associated Press. The other Sullivan, a former schoolteacher, changed his party affiliation to independent just eight days before the general election, as reported by the Alaska Beacon. This move was part of an alleged strategy to confuse voters and shift support away from incumbent Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan.
Alaska’s open voting system allowed candidates to claim any party affiliation without party vetting, making the scheme possible. The Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee (DSCC) and Peltola’s campaign reportedly orchestrated the move, recruiting former Peltola campaign manager Elisa Rios and former chief of staff Anton McParland to introduce a veteran Democratic operative named Jerid Kurtz. Kurtz allegedly informed a Peltola campaign aide that he had arrived in Petersburg, where the other Sullivan resides, according to the New York Times.
The other Sullivan joined the race just three days before the June 1 deadline, with Democratic strategist Amber Lee authoring a press release for his candidacy. Division of Elections Director Carol Beecher initially rejected his candidacy, stating it was not filed in good faith. However, Superior Court Judge Thomas Matthews allowed him to remain on the ballot for the primary. The Alaska Supreme Court later upheld this decision, allowing the other Sullivan to be on the ballot, which the DSCC and Peltola’s campaign celebrated.
The Department of Justice (DOJ) filed a lawsuit to block Alaska’s Senate results if Sullivan lost, but U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason blocked the lawsuit, citing insufficient explanation of the DOJ’s authority. The DOJ issued at least 30 subpoenas as part of its investigation into the alleged scheme.
Mary Peltola won by more votes than other Dan Sullivan pulled from Senator Sullivan. Peltola defeated Sullivan by about 13,000 votes. The other Sullivan garnered 4,760 votes. @DailyCaller https://t.co/lid2vW1XiL
President Donald Trump won Alaska in 2024 by a 54.5% to 41.4% margin, while Sullivan won his 2020 race by 12.7 points. Democrats flipped nine Senate seats, including Alaska, Texas, Kansas, and Iowa, as voters grew disillusioned with Trump’s handling of the economy, the Iran war, and corruption.
Source: Daily Caller