D.C. Court Blocks Pentagon from Discharging 27 Transgender Troops
Federal appeals court halts Pentagon’s plan to discharge 27 transgender service members, citing equal protection concerns.
2 min read
A federal appeals court in Washington, D.C., has blocked the Pentagon from discharging 27 transgender service members, ruling that the military’s policy of barring transgender individuals from serving violates the Constitution’s equal protection clause. The decision, issued by a 2-1 court, immediately enforced a prior ruling from June, which found the policy likely unconstitutional.
Supreme Court Delay Request Rejected
The Trump administration had sought a delay in the ruling while the Supreme Court deliberates whether to take up the case. However, the court denied the request, with two judges—Robert Wilkins and Judith Rogers—agreeing the policy is unconstitutional. Judge Justin Walker, in contrast, stated he would grant the delay, though his reasoning was not elaborated in the order.
Plaintiffs’ Service Record Recognized
Wilkins emphasized in his June ruling that the plaintiffs, who collectively served over 130 years and received more than 80 commendations, had served honorably and met all military standards. The court’s decision applies only to the 27 service members who initiated the lawsuit, not to other troops or those seeking to enlist.
Supreme Court Involvement in Similar Case
The ruling comes after the Supreme Court intervened in a similar case, United States v. Shilling, in May 2025, putting a Washington state court’s injunction on hold. Judge Walker noted that the 2025 case should guide the D.C. court due to similar arguments presented in both cases.
Government Defers to Pentagon on Military Standards
The Department of Justice argued that courts should defer to the Pentagon’s judgment on military readiness and qualification standards. Despite this, the court ruled that the policy’s constitutionality must be addressed, with the Supreme Court set to consider whether to take up the case in December.
Legal Battle Continues
The case, Talbott v. United States, No. 25-5087, remains in the courts as the administration continues to push for the Supreme Court’s review. This legal battle highlights the ongoing tension between military policy and constitutional rights, with the outcome potentially reshaping the future of transgender service members in the armed forces.
Source: Breitbart