Seabed Mining Review Looms as Trump’s Fast Track Faces Crucial Decision
Federal regulators are set to decide on seabed mining review by December, with potential implications for U.S. supply chains and international competition.
4 min read
By mid-December, federal regulators are expected to decide whether an American subsidiary of The Metals Company has made a strong enough case to move its Pacific seabed mining proposal into environmental review. The company disclosed the new timetable in a November 12 filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission. This decision is crucial for the company’s application for an exploration license and commercial recovery permit, which had previously been scheduled for a decision by the end of October.
Accelerated Review Process
In April 2025, President Donald Trump signed an executive order directing the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) to speed up seabed mining reviews in international waters. In January, NOAA changed its rules to allow eligible companies to apply for both an exploration license and a commercial recovery permit in one filing. This streamlined process makes sense for the agency, as it can review the full plan upfront and assess whether the company can fund the work, has the necessary equipment, and possesses the expertise to execute the project.
In August, NOAA stated that the application contained enough information to proceed with the review. Public comments were closed on October 19, and NOAA will use these comments to decide whether to certify the application. If certified, the agency will prepare an environmental impact statement and seek further public input. However, the review process is still pending, and the final decision is expected by December.
Strategic Implications and Industry Interest
A November 17 stock promotion highlighted the potential value of the project, estimating a $16 trillion opportunity based on a 2019 estimate of metals spread across a vast Pacific region between Hawaii and Mexico. The application covers one specific area within that region. The company’s success in securing this permit could have significant implications for U.S. supply chains, especially given the current reliance on China for critical metals.
McCall, a key advocate for the project, believes that Trump must approve the application before the new Congress is sworn in, given the Democratic sweep of the midterms. The Pentagon also has a stake in the decision, as China controls most of the world’s supply of critical metals, and the U.S. military can no longer purchase weapons made with materials sourced from China starting January 1. McCall emphasizes the need for a new, fast source of these metals, stating, “America needs a new source of these metals, and it needs one fast. The Motherlode is the only deposit big enough to break China’s grip.”
Technical and Logistical Challenges
Despite the strategic importance, the project faces several technical and logistical challenges. The company must extract the metal-bearing nodules from the seabed, transport them ashore, and then process them into usable materials. The cost of delivering the material to a factory is significantly higher than the price of the raw material in the ground. The port where the ship unloads and the processing plant that turns the cargo into usable metal are both critical factors in the project’s viability.
The Metals Company is still working on its commercial collection system and exploring existing overseas processing facilities or developing new ones in the United States. These logistical considerations are essential for ensuring that the project can deliver a viable supply chain for American manufacturers.
Environmental and Economic Considerations
The International Energy Agency reported that China accounted for 78% of cobalt refining in 2024, highlighting the need for a new supply source. A new supply could provide American manufacturers with more options, provided they can access usable metal at an affordable price. However, the environmental impact of seabed mining remains a concern, and the review process must address how the equipment could disturb the seabed, what measurements the company would need to take, and under what circumstances NOAA might order a pause if the project is approved.
The Metals Company has emphasized its commitment to transparency, stating it is still working on its commercial collection system and looking to secure existing overseas processing facilities or develop new ones in the United States. These steps are crucial for ensuring the project’s long-term success and sustainability.
Next Steps and Public Engagement
The administration’s decision in December will be pivotal. If NOAA certifies the application, the public should be informed about what the company demonstrated and when the environmental review can expect to begin. If more information is needed, NOAA should clearly outline what is required. The company can also help by providing details on the first commercial shipment, the processing facilities, and the conditions necessary for a buyer to sign a contract.
December could determine whether the project is ready for its next review. The ultimate payoff for the country would be when an American manufacturer can order the material, price it, and count on the next shipment. The speed of this process will be a key indicator of how much closer the project brings the U.S. to achieving energy independence and reducing its reliance on foreign suppliers.
Source: PJ Media