New Study Shows School Phone Bans May Help Close Learning Gaps
A Harvard study suggests strict cell phone bans in schools could help reverse learning losses from the pandemic.
2 min read
Recent research suggests that school cell phone bans may be helping close learning gaps left by the pandemic. National surveys indicate that over 90% of public schools enforce some form of cell phone restriction, with more than 40 states implementing total or partial bans. While the effects have not been immediate, a new Harvard study suggests that these bans may be having a measurable impact on student academic growth.
Study Reveals Positive Impact on Academic Growth
The Harvard study, which analyzed data from 3.3 million students in grades 3 through 10 across 4,600 U.S. schools, found that strict bans on cell phone use had the most significant effect on academic growth. The study used MAP scores, a widely used assessment in K–12 schools to measure student progress in subjects like reading, mathematics, and science.
The findings indicate that the annual gains from strict phone bans reversed about half the annual learning loss that students experienced in the years leading up to the pandemic. ‘It’s been a slow leak that has put U.S. 8th graders almost a year behind,’ said Thomas Kane, a professor at the Harvard Graduate School of Education. ‘Strict cellphone bans seem to plug about half of that leak.’
Reading and Math Show Improvement
The study found that the benefits of phone bans were evident in both math and reading, with students at all levels of achievement showing improvement. This was unexpected, as researchers had anticipated that low performers would benefit the most. ‘I think it’s really interesting and useful to know there’s no difference,’ said Professor Jacob.
Researchers also noted that the bans helped reduce the number of students experiencing a decline in reading scores. They attributed this to the fact that reading requires sustained focus, which is often disrupted by screen time.
Some Studies Remain Skeptical
However, not all studies agree. A separate study published in The Quarterly Journal of Economics found that using pouches to hold cell phones had ‘close to zero’ impact on student test scores, with any benefit not being statistically significant. Despite this, the new Harvard study is seen as more comprehensive, as it assessed individual student scores over time and across the country.
While some educators remain skeptical, the study highlights the potential long-term benefits of strict phone bans. ‘If [the benefit] really persists and accumulates over time, it really could be a meaningful benefit,’ said Brian Jacobs, a co-author of the April study.
Source: PJ Media